67 Main Street · Southampton Village

Fudge, ice creamand candy.

Under the blue awning on Main Street since 1984. Fudge cut to weight from the case, every ice cream flavor scooped or swirled to order, and shelves of candy from cotton candy to the penny case.

Order for pickup Call (631) 283-8108

40+: years on Main St
4.5★: 73 Google reviews
11am–10pm: open daily

The Fudge Company storefront with its blue awning and ice cream cone signs on Main Street in Southampton

Homemade candy since 1984(631) 283-8108

Call the shop — we'll have your box waiting.

(631) 283-8108

Glass case of fudge slabs and chocolate covered graham crackers with handwritten labels

The fudge case

Cut to weight, boxed at the counter.

Every slab is made in the shop and labeled by hand. Point at what you want, we cut it, weigh it and wrap it.

Chocolate Walnut$28/lb
Peanut Butter Chocolate$28/lb
Vanilla Maple Walnut$28/lb
Pumpkin$28/lb
Chocolate Caramel Swirl$28/lb
Penuche$28/lb

Also hand-dipped daily

Milk Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers · $14/box
Dark Chocolate Covered Graham Crackers · $14/box
Milk Chocolate Covered Caramels · $16/box
Chocolate Covered Pretzels · $12/bag

Ice cream & frozen yogurt

Every flavor made to order.

Hard scoop from the tubs, soft serve swirled at the machine, froyo sundaes and cones off the board. Cup, sugar cone or waffle cone.

Open tubs of Oreo, strawberry, mint and chocolate ice cream behind the freezer glass

Hand holding a Joy cup with two scoops of coffee chocolate chip ice cream on Main Street

The Fudge Co window with painted ice cream cones and homemade candy sign

Vanilla$6.75 / scoop
Chocolate$6.75 / scoop
Strawberry$6.75 / scoop
Oreo$6.75 / scoop
Mint Chocolate Chip$6.75 / scoop
Cookie Dough$6.75 / scoop
Coffee Chocolate Chip$6.75 / scoop
Black Raspberry$6.75 / scoop
Butter Pecan$6.75 / scoop
Vanilla Soft Serve$6.25 / cone
Chocolate Soft Serve$6.25 / cone
Low-Fat Vanilla Peanut Butter Froyo$7.00 / cup

Order ice cream for pickup (631) 283-8108

The candy aisle

Shelves of it, floor to ceiling.

Cotton candy bags on the rack, giant swirl lollipops on the wooden tree by the door, nostalgic boxes stacked on the racks, and the penny case the kids never leave alone.